A reconsideration request works when the manual action is truly fixed and the request proves it. Fix the cause across the whole site, keep records of what you did, then explain the problem, the cleanup and the result in plain, factual language. Vague or rushed requests are the ones that come back rejected.
When you can file one
A reconsideration request only applies to a manual action. That is a penalty applied by a human reviewer at Google, and it appears in Search Console under Security and Manual actions. The report shows the type of issue and often the affected pages. If nothing is listed there, there is nothing to reconsider. Our answer on how to know if you have a manual action shows where to look.
Before you write anything: fix the problem
Filing early is the most common mistake. Google asks you to resolve the issue first, across the site, not only on the examples it listed. The sample pages are a clue, not a full list.
| Manual action | What must be fixed first |
|---|---|
| Unnatural links to your site | Remove the manipulative links where you can, and disavow the rest. |
| Thin content with little or no added value | Rewrite, merge or remove the weak pages across the whole site. |
| Spam or hacked content | Clean the hack, close the hole it came through, and remove the injected pages. |
| Pure spam or user generated spam | Remove the spam content and tighten how new content is accepted or moderated. |
For link problems, read our guide on the unnatural links manual action. For content problems, read the guide on the thin content manual action.
Why requests get rejected
Most rejections come down to a handful of causes. Knowing them saves weeks, because each attempt takes time to be reviewed.
Before you submit
Check these first
If any line on this list is a no, the request is not ready.
Reviewers read many requests. A clear, honest, well documented one stands out from a vague one.
Pre submission checklist
- The cleanup covers the whole site, not just the sample pages
- Every bad link or weak page has been handled or documented
- The documentation opens without a login
- The request names the real cause
- Nothing new that breaks the same policy has been published
Another common cause is repeat offending. If new spam content or new paid links appear while your request is pending, Google can see that the problem is not gone. Freeze risky activity until the review is finished.
Partial fixes and sample pages
Google often lists only a few example URLs in the manual action. Owners fix those and file. Reviewers then check the rest of the site and find more of the same. Treat every example as a pattern: find all the pages or links that share it, and deal with each one. For link problems, that means pulling the full backlink data from several sources and not relying on a single report. For content problems, it means reviewing every page that matches the pattern, not only the ones Google named.
What to document
Reviewers cannot see your effort unless you show it. Keep a record as you work:
- The pages or links you found, and how you found them
- What you changed or removed, and when
- Proof of attempts to remove bad links, such as contact emails and replies
- The disavow file you submitted, if links were the issue
- Before and after examples of the content you improved
Put the records in a shared document and link to it from the request. Make sure the link can be opened without a login.
How to write the request
1. State the issue
Name the manual action as Search Console lists it, in one sentence. Do not argue that it was unfair.
2. Explain the cause
Say what caused it, honestly. If a previous agency built the links, say that. Owning the cause shows you understand it.
3. Describe the cleanup
Summarise what you did, in order, with numbers you can back up from your records. Keep it short and link to the detail.
4. Say how you will prevent it
One or two lines on what has changed so it does not return, such as a new process for approving content or links.
5. Submit from Search Console
Use the Request review button in the Manual actions report. Then wait. Google tells you the outcome in Search Console and by message.
After you submit
Do not file again while the request is pending. Our answer on how long a reconsideration request takes explains what to expect. If Google lifts the action, rankings do not always bounce straight back. The pages and links that were suppressed may have lost the value they used to carry, and recovery can mean rebuilding.
When to call for help
Get help when you cannot find all of the problem, when a request has already been rejected, or when you inherited the site and do not know its link or content history. Those cases need evidence work before any request is written.
Our Google penalty recovery service handles the cleanup, the documentation and the request. Ask for a free SEO triage and we will tell you honestly whether a request is the right next step.
FAQ
Questions owners ask us
Can I file a reconsideration request without a manual action?
There is nothing to reconsider without one. If a drop is not listed under Manual actions in Search Console, it was not a manual penalty, and a request will not help. Look at algorithmic causes and technical faults instead.
What should I do if my request is rejected?
Read the response. Google usually gives an example of what is still wrong. Fix that issue and look for more of the same, then submit again with fuller documentation. Rejection usually means the cleanup was incomplete.
Should I write a long emotional appeal?
No. A short, factual request works better. State the issue, what you did to fix it, and link to your documentation. Reviewers want evidence that the problem is resolved, not an apology or a story.
Get started